College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

Commentary: Off-site home game a success

By Sam Werner

Associate Sports Editor

Print this article

Published: Monday, November 2, 2009

Updated: Monday, November 2, 2009

wsu-weber/football-WSU-weber-02.jpg

ANDREW WEBER/The Observer

Notre Dame’s matchup with Washington State in San Antonio’s Alamodome wasn’t a sellout, but Irish coach Charlie Weis compared the atmosphere at the off-site home game to that of a bowl game.

When you mentioned to someone that Notre Dame was playing Washington State in San Antonio, the most common response was “why?”

I’ll even admit that I was skeptical of the first “off-site home game” that was part of Notre Dame’s new 7-4-1 scheduling model.

But after a weekend in San Antonio, it’s clear that the idea is a great one, even if the execution could use a little improvement.

The weekend kicked off Friday night with a pep rally in front of the Alamo, one of America’s most iconic venues. Even though the pep rally wasn’t the most raucous I’ve ever seen, the crowd itself was a sight to behold. Notre Dame estimated that close to 8,000 fans attended the rally, and the crowd spilled out onto the adjacent streets.

The speakers included former Notre Dame running back Allen Pinkett and radio broadcaster Don Criqui, and the Band of the Fighting Irish played all the crowd favorites — and threw in a little Lone Star flair by playing “Deep in the Heart of Texas.”

After the pep rally ended, the crowd moved down to San Antonio’s famed River Walk.  Random “Let’s go, Irish” chants started up and down the river. And a few fans rode down the river back and forth waving a Notre Dame flag and cheering for the Irish.

“I thought that this was a great venue,” Irish coach Charlie Weis said. “I mean, I thought it was awesome. And I think our players thought that. There was so much excitement in the air. I mean, I give credit to our Notre Dame fans.”

On Saturday, San Antonio might as well have been South Bend. Irish fans owned the streets and the River Walk, but there was a surprising amount of Washington State crimson to be seen, too.

As for the game itself, the Alamodome was about as close to Notre Dame Stadium as you could get, minus Touchdown Jesus. Mike Collins, the voice of Notre Dame Stadium, provided the public address and Officer Tim McCarthy even had a fourth quarter message for the fans.

Numerous people compared the atmosphere of the weekend to that of a bowl game, which is tough to replicate in the middle of the season.

The biggest positive aspect of the weekend, though, was the opportunity it gave to Irish fans in the Lone Star State. For a lot of Notre Dame supporters across the country, it just isn’t possible to get out to a game in South Bend. While there may not have been a huge student presence at the game, it’s a safe bet that for many of the alumni and subway alumni in Texas, this was their first Irish game in quite a few years, if not ever.

“When you get into an experiment like this — and this is an experiment, taking a home game on the road — you need a great partner,” Notre Dame Athletic Director Jack Swarbrick said at the pep rally. “And we couldn’t have a better partner for our first off-site game than San Antonio.”

That being said, the weekend wasn’t perfect. Despite the best efforts of Notre Dame and its alumni clubs in Texas, the game did not sell out. If you’re counting this as a true home game, it’s the non-sellout since the infamous 1973 Thanksgiving game against Air Force. The announced attendance was 53,407, about 82 percent of the Alamodome’s capacity of 65,000.

The poor ticket sales could probably be attributed to the weak opponent. As nice as the Washington State fans were, the Cougars just aren’t the type of team Notre Dame should be aiming for with these games. Imagine what the atmosphere would have been like if the game had been against a top tier team like Miami or Georgia, to name two.

Hopefully, Swarbrick and the athletic department will learn from this weekend and make improvements for next year’s game against Army in Yankee Stadium. In all, though, it was a surprisingly positive experience in San Antonio for fans, coaches and players alike.

“If the rest of them go like this, sign me up,” Weis said. “It really was a great experience.”

The views expressed in this column are those of the author and not necessarily those of The Observer.
Contact Sam Werner at swerner@nd.edu

Comments

12 comments
Your name
Tue Nov 3 2009 12:39
I was blessed with the opportunity to attend the Notre Dame game in San Antonio. I thought it was the perfect location to host this type of game. I attended the final four there in 2004 and this ranks right up there with that "once in a lifetime" experience. You have the River Walk, the Alamo and an easy walk to the stadium from downtown. The ND tailgater at Sunset Station was first class and the pep rally was really cool with the Alamo lit up in the background. I hope San Antonio gets in the rotation to host a game like this for many years to come. Sign me up, I am there.
Ted Hake
Tue Nov 3 2009 10:58
I live in Edinburg, Texas, on the Mexican border at the very southern tip of Texas. My daughter graduated last May and attended many home games during her four years at Notre Dame. However, the rest of my family has never been able to travel all the way to South Bend for a football game. Ironically, my daughter was unable to attend last Saturday's game because she is currently serving with the Peace Corps in Mozambique, Africa. However, because of the decision to play a home game in San Antonio, my wife, my epileptic 25-year-old son (whose entire life revolves around sports), my 13-year-old daughter, and I finally were able to attend a Notre Dame football game. We certainly enjoyed the pep rally in front of the Alamo (although we were disappointed tat none of the players or coahces attended) and the game. We certainly thank those who made the decision to play at the Alamodome and give those of us who live quite far from South Bend a change to expericience a Notre Dame football weekend. Hopefully, you will return to San Antonio, which is very known for its ability to host major sporting events, in a few years.
Ted Hake
Tue Nov 3 2009 10:56
I live in Edinburg, Texas, on the Mexican border at the very southern tip of Texas. My daughter graduated last May and attended many home games during her four years at Notre Dame. However, the rest of my family has never been able to travel all the way to South Bend for a football game. Ironically, my daughter was unable to attend last Saturday's game because she is currently serving with the Peace Corps in Mozambique, Africa. However, because of the decision to play a home game in San Antonio, my wife, my epileptic 25-year-old son (whose entire life revolves around sports), my 13-year-old daughter, and I finally were able to attend a Notre Dame football game. We certainly enjoyed the pep rally in front of the Alamo (although we were disappointed tat none of the players or coahces attended) and the game. We certainly thank those who made the decision to play at the Alamodome and give those of us who live quite far from South Bend a change to expericience a Notre Dame football weekend. Hopefully, you will return to San Antonio, which is very known for its ability to host major sporting events, in a few years.
TexasTIm
Mon Nov 2 2009 22:28
We had a great time too. I went to the 06 Fiesta Bowl and 0 Sugar Bowl and this ranks right up there with those experiences and ND owned the whole deal. The Washington St. fans were having a blast, (I partied with them at Dicks on Friday night) the venue was perfect, the weather was beautiful, and the team performed well. THis is a new approach to college football that we should embrace. I can't wait for the Army game next year. GO IRISH!!!
GRC '69
Mon Nov 2 2009 20:38
Give me UT in Austin and a return in SB anytime over anybody in the Alamodome. Why do we want to keep the 7-4-1 abomination that Kevin "they'll forget football for hockey" White left us? 6-5-1 works -- why try to do the impossible? Even Michigan (and Tenn) will play at U Conn, but we won't.
charlotte
Mon Nov 2 2009 18:49
Notre Dame coming to San Antonio was a dream come true for fans who will never be able to get to South Bend to see them play. The weather was absolutely gorgeous. From all the feedback I heard from out of town fans, San Antonio was an excellent choice. The game would have been sold out if the Spurs had not been playing, if it had not been Halloween and if Notre Dame had played a more formidable opponent . Both San Antonio and Notre Dame did a great job and made me proud as a San Antonian and as a Notre Dame fan. Y'all come back now.
anti-Monkeypox
Mon Nov 2 2009 14:29
Monkeypox: Here's a comment on ratings:

"NOTRE DAME RATINGS UP 24 PERCENT: Through the first five broadcasts of the season Notre Dame viewership on NBC Sports has jumped 24 percent compared to the first five broadcasts from last year (4.2 million vs. 3.4 million).

The Oct. 17 USC-Notre Dame game on NBC Sports drew 6.5 million viewers, the most for a Notre Dame game on NBC since September 9, 2006 when the Penn St.-Notre Dame game drew 6.9 million viewers."

SD Irish
Mon Nov 2 2009 13:52
Hey Monkeypox,

Why are you on this board if ND is no longer relevant? Laugh at the haters, they can't get enough of us. ND is 6-2 and making their move. 2009 has been fun, but 2010 will be about dominance.

Monkeypox
Mon Nov 2 2009 13:36
What a joke Notre Lame has become. You played one of the worst football teams in the country and act like it was a "bowl game".

Notice that this fawning homer article didn't mention TV ratings? That's because this wonderful game drew a .5 rating.

Notre Shame fans are the most delusional in the country. Wha color is the sky in your world?

Larry Mellon Lt Col (USAF ret)
Mon Nov 2 2009 13:00
It was a fabulous day in San Antonio! A marvelous opportunity for Notre Dame to showcase the ND persona, up close and personal, to the kids in this area. When I explained why the Irish were playing here: recruiting, community involvement, pep rally, mass, marching band, etc., everyone thought it was a wonderful idea!!! And it was. The outcome was superb both on the field and off of it.

GO IRISH

trey
Mon Nov 2 2009 12:40
Ive been to Irish true away games, ND home games, and now this. I have to say, this was the most exciting and energetic crowd I've ever been a part of. Home games, are of course, their own mystical thing and nothing can quite compare to that. Away games are all about the on-field product itself as the away fans don't like you and occasionally are rude and disrespectful. This was a middle ground that was tilted quite a bit towards a home game atmosphere. Imagine 40,000 people coming to South Bend for their first time, and that's what this game was like. Everyone was juiced up, excited, and ready to scream. Let's get a better opponent next time, but all in all a great game!
Rusty
Mon Nov 2 2009 12:30
Great Experience is RIGHT!! This was my first Notre Dame game after having been a lifelong fan of the Irish. Thank you Notre Dame for bringing the game to me and you are always welcome in San Antonio. Come back again and we'll sell out the dome!






log out