College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

Staff Predictions: Notre Dame vs. Navy

By

Print this article

Published: Thursday, November 5, 2009

Updated: Friday, November 6, 2009

Make Your Pick

Which Observer beat writer's score will be the most accurate?

View results

Bill Brink, Managing Editor

Ready yourselves for frustration, because Navy's triple option always causes it. Quarterback Ricky Dobbs runs the option well and has an absurd 16 rushing touchdowns this season. Now cue Manti Te'o hitting the gap and destroying the pitch man just as he gets the ball because the defensive line has sealed up the fullback's hole and Darius Fleming pressured Dobbs to force the pitch. That won't happen every time, but it'll happen enough to secure a win for Notre Dame. Jimmy Clausen has been ridiculous without Michael Floyd. With him back, even as a decoy, the rest of the offense opens up and scores a ton of points on a solid but overmatched Navy defense. Navy will control the clock and score, but not nearly enough to win.

FINAL SCORE: Notre Dame 34, Navy 17

Michael Bryan, Associate Sports Editor

The return of Michael Floyd is absolutely huge for this Irish team. With Floyd, Notre Dame can hang with almost every team in the country just on the strength of their passing attack. Even if he does not play considerable time against Navy, the game experience will be valuable for Floyd to be ready against a tough Pittsburgh team. The Notre Dame offense should be able to control the line of scrimmage and continue to dominate through the air. The run defense is playing very well, and Manti Te’o should have a big game against the triple option attack. Ricky Dobbs will have success at times, but the Irish offense will be too much.

FINAL SCORE: Notre Dame 37, Navy 17

Matt Gamber, Sports Editor

Navy lost to Temple last week, but that was without its best player, quarterback Ricky Dobbs. Dobbs should be back running the Midshipmen's classic option attack, which the Irish defense shut down for most of last year's matchup. The same should happen again, as the maligned secondary should get a bit of respite because of Navy's run, run, run style of play. The offense will need to play mistake-free football as it has all year to maximize its limited possessions, and Charlie Weis said he’d be sure to involve all his weapons, including the newly returned Michael Floyd. As always, Notre Dame is a much bigger, faster, more talented team than Navy, and this year, the Irish will just be too much for the Midshipmen. This one won’t be close.

FINAL SCORE: Notre Dame 27, Navy 7

Sam Werner, Associate Sports Editor

After a break last week in San Antonio, Jimmy Clausen will likely have to play the whole game against the Midshipmen. Notre Dame is more talented than Navy, to be sure, but the option-style offense will keep the game closer than it probably should be. The Irish won’t be able to control the clock for nearly 40 minutes like they did against the Cougars, and Navy always comes to South Bend fired up and ready to play. That being said, though, the Midshipmen (or anyone else in the country, for that matter) will have trouble stopping a Notre Dame offense with both Golden Tate and Michael Floyd in the lineup. Robert Hughes could also have another big day against an undersized, if opportunistic, Navy defense.

FINAL SCORE: Notre Dame 38, Navy 20

Comments

10 comments
Hogfan
Sun Nov 8 2009 17:53
Man oh Man did you guys blow it?
Hire Craig B
Sun Nov 8 2009 16:05
Nice prediction Craig B.
The Observer staff is clearly drinking Charlie's Kool Aid.
ND Alum 1982
Sat Nov 7 2009 23:38
I hope this loss finally puts an end to the Weis era at ND. Losing to Navy twice in three years is pathetic.
THE shepdaddy
Sat Nov 7 2009 10:57
FEAR THE GOAT. GO NAVY.
ND Fan 75
Fri Nov 6 2009 18:02
Momentum and ND go hand in hand...Especially when it's bolstered by the return of Floyd. I have a feeling that this will be a higher scoring game for the Irish than anyone thinks. Mark my words...42 - 17 Irish!
dulacer96
Fri Nov 6 2009 16:58
With Allen not being able to play, Floyd just coming back and our atrocious D, we need the luck of the Irish to beat Navy. Final prediction: ND 24, Navy 21 with a 4Q TD by the Irish to win it.
Tim
Fri Nov 6 2009 15:35
Craig B says...."Navy 21, ND 17 - This game will lead to departure of Mr. Weiss."

I say, who is this Mr. Weiss fellow your referencing?

GO IRISH!

bronzenboy
Fri Nov 6 2009 15:32
you guys are hilarious -- ND never beats Navy by the scores you're predicting. Get ready for a battle to the end.
Craig B.
Fri Nov 6 2009 14:08
Navy 21, ND 17 - This game will lead to departure of Mr. Weiss.
NDBounce
Fri Nov 6 2009 11:24
Do not forget that Navy's game plan limits the Time of Possession of their opponent. Even with Floyd back, I doubt that the IRISH will have the ball enough to rack up 38 points as Sam suggests. I do think the IRISH will win this game, but it will be something closer to 30-16, with Navy kicking 3FG's, and the IRISH having 4 TD's, 1 FG and 1 failed PAT.






log out