Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

How Catholic is Notre Dame?

Published: Thursday, September 29, 2011

Updated: Wednesday, September 12, 2012 13:09

This is a question that is asked somewhat frequently around here. And since many of those asking the question say that the answer is "not too Catholic" or that Notre Dame has lost its soul, I feel compelled to write a few words to the contrary. Notre Dame is a very Catholic place.

I attended the University of Notre Dame as an undergraduate student, 1972-1976. As a student, I found Notre Dame to be the most Catholic place I had ever been to in my life. I loved it.

After graduation I returned to Notre Dame in 1977 to study for the priesthood. During my years at Moreau Seminary and while studying for the Master of Divinity degree, I found Notre Dame to be a very Catholic place. I loved it.

From 1983 until 2009, I was assigned to work in Holy Cross apostolates in Oregon and in Arizona. I returned to Notre Dame on average three times a year during those 26 years. During my years away, I began to hear rumblings about the Catholic nature of Notre Dame. The controversy surrounding the commencement visit of the President of the United States in 2008 made this question the talk of the nation. Some of my brother priests found it necessary to write articles and letters questioning the Catholic character of Notre Dame.

For 19 of the 26 years that I was away, I served the Church as a pastor. Both in Oregon and in Arizona I was repeatedly struck time and time again by the love, respect, admiration and affection that the people of God have for Notre Dame. Notre Dame is dearly loved by millions and millions of Catholics, not just in the United States, but the world over. And they love it because it is Catholic.

In July of 2009, I was assigned to live and work here at Notre Dame. Through living in Dillon, celebrating the Eucharist in many hall chapels and being around students, I have found Notre Dame to be as Catholic as it ever was. To me this spirit is found everywhere — in our Sunday night masses, in our students, in the staff and in the literally hundreds of programs that are part of Notre Dame life. I find that Notre Dame is still deeply committed to serving the Church, perhaps more now than even when I was a student here.

On Sept. 11, 2011, the Office of the President and the Office of Campus Ministry organized an outdoor Mass in remembrance of the 10th anniversary of Sept. 11. The Mass was beautiful beyond words. As a priest I sat in the front rows facing the altar, so I had no idea how many students were at the Mass until communion. When I walked into the congregation to bring communion, there were students everywhere. There were students for as far as I could see. As I walked back to the altar after communion, there were students kneeling on the grass in prayer. I won't forget this image.

And then there was a candlelight procession from the Hesburgh Library to the Grotto. I was deeply moved by the prayerfulness of the students as they walked silently in procession. And I thought to myself ... what's all this nonsense about how Catholic is Notre Dame? An event like this Mass reveals the deep faith that is part of Notre Dame. It is at the heart of Notre Dame.

Some might say that this Mass does not show that Notre Dame is very Catholic. But I would argue that indeed it does. Our theology shows itself best in our instincts, and so does our life of prayer and faith. I am repeatedly inspired by the deep faith at Notre Dame.

One day last week I received an email from the President of Dillon Hall where I am privileged to live. The email was announcing an upcoming dance. Part of the email read, "Tickets will be on sale in the 24 hour lounge tonight after Mass." I wonder how many other universities and colleges have residence hall presidents sending emails saying, "tickets will be on sale after Mass." It's just how Notre Dame is.

Notre Dame is Catholic, very Catholic. I am very grateful to be working and living at Notre Dame. It is the very Catholic place that it has always been. It strives today, as it always has, to serve the Church. I love Notre Dame.

Fr. Joe Corpora, CSC, works with the ACE movement and is a priest-in-residence in Dillon Hall. He is a sinner whose sins are forgiven. And he loves anything made with tomato sauce. He can be reached at Joseph.V.Corpora.2@nd.edu

The views expressed in this column are those of the author and not necessarily those of The Observer.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

22 comments

ND Peace Minor '11
Wed Oct 5 2011 16:37
Notre Dame will always hold a special place in my heart, mind, and soul. The church plays a vital role in the the campus, even today. Classrooms have crucifixes in them. Mass at the basilica after football games becomes a staple to many visitors. Students from other colleges came weekly to Notre Dame dorm hall masses. Each residence hall has a person of the church that lives there, many of whom make personal connections with the students. I believe that Notre Dame evolves with the ideal of growing further spiritually each year, while individuals of its community may wax and wane as events occur in one's life and in the world. It is good to remember that one person's opinion, be it a president of a school or a visiting guest speaker such as the President of the United States, does not determine the opinion for the rest of the school.
MG Sikorski
Tue Oct 4 2011 14:38
All you "anonymous" cowards - guess what? ND IS Catholic, as Catholic as your local parish, like it or not. It's reality. Take off your rose-colored glasses. What would make ND Catholic in YOUR eyes? If it was full of all non-sinners and virgins? Wake up--that scenario doesn't exist at your parish or at ND, but that doesn't mean people in both places aren't striving to be Christ-like. And as far as the Obama visit--get over it! Allowing someone who isn't pro-life to speak there doesn't make ND any less Catholic than it makes you all any time you talk to a person who sins, which is every single day. Hello!
ND Alum, 76
Mon Oct 3 2011 15:58
ND as catholic as your local parish - that's a dangerous statement given the number of parishes I have attended mass at where the teaching authority of the church as established by Jesus Christ is not honored in either the liturgy or the preaching. It isn't a question of the parish being sinless - if it is on earth as part of the church militant it definitely has sinful members. The question is recognition of that pesky teaching authority as established by Jesus, because if that teaching authority is not submitted to, then neither is there a true seeking to be Christ like - because one who truly seeks to be Christ like will seek direction from the teaching authority He set up.
MG Sikorski
Mon Oct 3 2011 14:45
All you "anonymous" cowards - guess what? ND IS Catholic, as Catholic as your local parish, like it or not. It's reality. Take off your rose-colored glasses. What would make ND Catholic in YOUR eyes? If it was full of all non-sinners and virgins? Wake up--that scenario doesn't exist at your parish or at ND, but that doesn't mean people in both places aren't striving to be Christ-like. And as far as the Obama visit--get over it! Allowing someone who isn't pro-life to speak there doesn't make ND any less Catholic than it makes you all any time you talk to a person who sins, which is every single day. Hello!
Ken
Fri Sep 30 2011 20:32
I'm surprised that some "Catholic" commentators here do not understand that abortion is a "Non-Negotiable" issue. They lump it with "social justice" and "worker's rights" apparently without fully grasping the depth of the abortion evil. Would they understand the seriousness of this evil if 53,000,000 USA ten-year-old children had been slaughtered since 1973? Would they still say that social justice and their paycheck is equally important? How can a real Catholic be so blind? Are they paying attention at mass? Surely there are many REAL Catholics at ND... no doubt. But the administration has clearly defected to the other side.
Alfredo
Fri Sep 30 2011 10:23
Compare and contrast this article with Bishop Rhoades' article on Holy Cross College in this week's edition of Today's Catholic.
Anonymous
Thu Sep 29 2011 19:54
As a recent Notre Dame grad, I can say that the student body is most certainly Catholic on the whole. So are the alumni. And the priests and priest rectors.

More importantly, however, is that the professors are less and less Catholic and the ADMINISTRATION is at times counter-productive in terms of fostering Catholicism.

In sum, if not for the students and alumni, Notre Dame would not be very Catholic at all, save for a few priests who live on the campus. To repeat what someone said earlier, ND is more and more a place where Catholics get an education, not a place to get a Catholic Education.

Anonymous
Thu Sep 29 2011 18:08
Regarding the abortion issue as a meter of Catholicity, get over it! We're all Catholic, we all KNOW abortion is wrong. I like what Wyoming's Alan Simpson said when it became an issue during the last Supreme Court nomination: "No one is going around saying, 'get an abortion, they're great!'' Statistically, abortions came way down in the last decade. This is good, and of course, it will be better when there are none. I agree that the neo-conservatives need to quit using this their measurement on every possible issue.
Anonymous
Thu Sep 29 2011 17:59
Thank YOU BP Young, Irish Mom & Fr. Corpora! I agree with you all, expecially the point that the neo-cons use abortion as a pivitol issue to justify what they don't like, including present administration. And yes, the liberals are still here because the truth is liberal and so are the facts.
Anonymous
Thu Sep 29 2011 17:45
Wow!!! It's amazing: Father accomplishes to say ABSOLUTELY NOTHING about what constitutes ND's "very Catholic" nature, other than the fact that he himself finds it to be so! By the same logic, the US is Catholic, since there are beautiful processions that happen in the US. The question is not whether or not Catholic things happen within the campus territory of ND (a point that itself could be vetted in terms of liturgical propriety and doctrinal orthodoxy), but whether or not that which makes ND to be ND is itself Catholic. Another question: Where are the influences upon society wrought by the Catholic identity of ND through its alumni?

If you go to ND, you definitely have the opportunity to find vibrant faith and genuine Catholicism. And it's not hiding. It's present and alive, particularly in the Law School. However, it's simply a cozy feeling to suggest that ND is, as such, "very Catholic."

Phil
Thu Sep 29 2011 17:16
Without doubt there are good Catholics at ND. What does that have to do with the fact that the institution embarasses the Catholic Church at nearly every turn. What Catholic (true to the faith) wouldn't be pleased to see ND start following the teachings of the Church, following the leadership of the Bishops, and most of all standing with the Church. ND is ill..... Smokers aren't bothered by other smokers. This may be the only explanation as to how anyone could be blind to the corruption and scandal that ND has caused.
ND Alum, 76
Thu Sep 29 2011 17:11
I suppose your opinion of ND's catholicity depends a great deal on how you define catholic. My experience between 72 and 76 was a place full of external piety and there was a lot of seeking to do the heroic. The problem was then that few on campus really knew and practiced their faith on any more than that external or heroic (with some really strange and limited definitions of heroic) piety and practice. With a few notable exceptions, most that I encountered on campus during that time were cultural Christians seeking to make their mark on the world in ways that would be nearly indistinguishable from atheistic communists, including a number of ordained clergy. Modernist heresies denying the sovereign power of God and that He has worked and continues to work physical miracles (as opposed to only "spiritual" miracles) along with declaring "independence" from Rome's oversight in the name of being a more "effective" university (see Land O Lakes declaration in 1968) appeared to this observer to be the norm on campus. To me, being a Catholic means acceptance of the teaching authority established by Jesus Christ and showing that acceptance by submitting to the Pope and his local bishop. If that acceptance and obedience is not there, then neither is the protection given in promise to the church - that the gates of hell shall not prevail against it.
BP Young
Thu Sep 29 2011 15:40
As yet another "Irish Mom" I agree with what the other has written. Thank you , Father. I feel the same as you do as I have watched the young people on campus at mass and in their service work at home and overseas. I also agree with the comment at the top that if there is a lack of Christian teaching it will be that we need to up our social justice cred. The Center for Social Concerns is such a symbol of loving, giving and sharing. As an aside, how many of you naysayers were you protesting the latest execution? I know there was a prayer service at Duncan Hall to mark the event. I was so pleased to hear that.
The neo-conservative, myopic, one issue Catholics would like the purge the Church of those of us who look at a broader picture. We're still here-and many of us are at Notre Dame. Love thee.....
Anonymous
Thu Sep 29 2011 14:05
Yeah, its very vocal on certain issues, such as abortion, and...that's about it. The ND administration runs the school like a corporation and sells the issue that brings in money from alumni. As a current student, I am quite disappointed with both the school hierarchy and the student body in general with failing to give equal attention to the other aspects of Catholic Social Teaching. What about support for the worker and unions? What about standing up for and fighting on behalf of those who have been wronged by the creators of this economic recession?
Anonymous
Thu Sep 29 2011 13:48
It is a Catholic place that offers an education, but is it a place that offers a Catholic education?
Anonymous
Thu Sep 29 2011 12:35
Notre Dame had a priest arrested who had the courage to "live" his faith. The campus-Catholic- did not protest, did not support their faith and home from evil. It is the faithful that are Catholic.
Anonymous
Thu Sep 29 2011 12:28
Be careful that you don't mistake beauty and a reverent appearance, as well as good attendance, for heroic and faithful Catholicism. When ND can put it on the line for pro-life, pro-family issues, THEN you can lift them high as Catholic.
Anonymous
Thu Sep 29 2011 10:49
Are we only able to determine catholicity by one issue alone. Our way or don't engage nor come near our highway. What about thie issues of capitol punishment, poverty etc.
Please do not think I am not pro life however the same factors that are the cause of no relationships in the congress may immobilize our mission. Relationships and progress are interdependant. The good news is the engagement of the students in the holy eucharist.
AB '80
Thu Sep 29 2011 10:13
ND - go to mass and complain about abortion - yeah, that's as catholic as they wanna be.
ND alum, 07
Thu Sep 29 2011 09:33
I agree with you, Father Corpora. After graduating from Notre Dame, I attended graduate school at another Catholic (Jesuit) university, and am now working at a third Catholic (in this case, Marianist) university. When attending a weekday mass during graduate school, I was often the only student present--something that never was the case at the Basilica. Coed dorms are the norm at both of these schools, and rules like parietals non-existent. At Notre Dame, our faith pervades campus life, from the crosses in the classrooms to chapels and resident priests in the dorms, in a way that it does not at other Catholic universities. Notre Dame comes under criticism simply because it is the most visible Catholic university in the US, and much of this criticism is undeserved.




log out