Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

The walk-on tradition

Letter to the Editor

Published: Wednesday, February 3, 2010

Updated: Thursday, February 4, 2010 00:02

 As a third generation legacy child, I was a Notre Dame fan from day one. My Grandpa and his four kids, including my mom, are all proud to call themselves alumni of Notre Dame. This University is one of the most prestigious in the world: a Catholic school that excels in every area. However, these days there are a number of prestigious universities out there. But what sets this school apart can't be measured in GPAs or trophies: it's the tradition. Tradition is why alums give so much back to the school, why the football stadium is sold out every home game (no matter how bad the season), why we join arms at the end of every game and chant the Alma Mater, and why my family and I love this University so much. It is a very powerful thing that permeates almost every inch of this beautiful campus and it's why my kids and grandkids will love this school years from now. That said, a very prominent tradition is about to be cast aside: football walk-ons.

Walk-ons have been a tradition of Notre Dame football since the time of that famous five foot nothin', 100 and nothin', defensive player with barely a speck of talent. This tradition has continued year after year, most notably with special teams walk-on Mike Anello. A few friends of mine were planning on trying out for next year's team this spring and called the football office to find out when tryouts were. What they eventually found out was that the new head coach Brian Kelly and his staff were not going to have walk-on tryouts this year. Furthermore, they found that some of the current walk-ons were being cut. If this is not the case, I ask that the staff release some information to clarify and I will stand corrected. I understand that we are in a year of transition, and that there are an infinite number of things that keep coach Kelly and his staff more than busy, and that they are working incredibly hard.
 
I'm not going to lie, during coach Kelly's press conference when he announced he would be head coach here, I was really excited. He talked of how he would listen to the football games with the awe and wonder that so many fans do, how coaching here was his dream job, and how he left a team that he just took to the Sugar Bowl to coach our team with a 12 and 12 regular season record in the past two years. I thought to myself, "This guy was meant for this job. This guy gets what Notre Dame is about." However, it's like he said in that same speech, "There's a football coach, and then there's a football coach at Notre Dame. Because nobody ... nobody does it like Notre Dame." So to whom it may concern, please don't cut the walk-ons. Please hold tryouts in the spring. Please find the time like every coach before you has. I know it must be difficult for you and I might sound like an ignorant student. Nonetheless, if my pleas are unheard, I will still love this school, this team, and everything associated, because nobody does it like Notre Dame.
 
Nate Greenberg
freshman
Keough Hall
Feb. 2

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

14 comments

BK
Sat Feb 6 2010 00:01
Brian Kelly cares only about Brian Kelly! Haven't you guys noticed? Really classy how he deserted his UC team before their big game! Watch out ND, there will be a classy transition to the NFL by BK!
Anonymous
Fri Feb 5 2010 13:33
I actually know the words to the alma mater, and I don't know the more obscure lyrics to the fight song.

I guess I should know both....

Panger
Fri Feb 5 2010 12:16
Alum '09--For 50 plus years the Alma Mater was last song the band played for the students that bothered to stick around and nobody thought to change it until Charlie Weis moved it to the first song after the game. The Alma Mater is too slow, nobody really knows the words and lets be honest, it sounds like something that was written for George Gipp's funeral.

When the game is over, have the team come over to the student section and sing the best fight song in the world. Everyone knows the words, the song is exciting and it was done this way FOREVER. Charlie Weis made a lot of bad decisions at Notre Dame, and this is just another one that needs to be rectified.

Tim Dougherty, '07
Fri Feb 5 2010 11:52
Josh Schmidt is another notable recent walk-on player to point out. He wasn't a preferred walk-on, but after a year or two in interhall, he walked on as a fullback and got significant minutes under Willingham and was very productive catching the ball out of the backfield and occasionally--but not as often as he should--ran a power personnel set with Powers-Neal at tailback. He gave up a fifth year of eligibility in the 2005 season to move on in life with his new bride. Meanwhile, the ND fans that remember him wish he were the one instead of Schwapp going out for the fullback screen in the fourth quarter of the SC game.

If the new staff believes it can run more efficiently with fewer bodies, that 's their prerogative. But there is certainly value in taking some of these walk-ons every year.

Alum '09
Fri Feb 5 2010 11:31
Panger - The Alma Mater is played right after the game so that the players can sing it with the rest of the student body. I highly doubt that the players would stick around for the entire postgame show to sing the Alma Mater at the end. I wouldn't expect them to wait around that long--most of the student body doesn't even stick around that long!
Panger
Fri Feb 5 2010 00:24
While we're whining about lost traditions, how about ND move the Alma Mater BACK to the last song the band plays before they leave the field. It was that way from at least the mid 1950's till Weis made the switch. As much as I love the Alma Mater, right after the game the song is a total downer.
Another '73 alum
Thu Feb 4 2010 22:59
First truly disappointing thing I've heard from our new coach's mouth. I'm hoping he'll re-consider. There is a rich tradition in college football of the walk-on, and the most storied and tradition-laden program in the country dropping this is not a good harbinger, I fear. Perhaps Mike Oriard, Ara, Lou, and others could help this idea get a fresh review.
Anonymous
Thu Feb 4 2010 21:19
Great article, Nate. I am very happy that students like you are at Notre Dame!
Anonymous
Thu Feb 4 2010 19:12
Kelly's job is to win football games. His job is not to allow everyone to feel warm and fuzzy while watching Rudy. It's his team, and it's his right to do what he thinks will win football games.
Anonymous
Thu Feb 4 2010 19:11
I agree Nate, some of us have been training for a long time for this. It breaks my heart to know that we'll never be given the chance that Rudy and Mike Anello got. Kelly talks about wanting guys that play 4 quarters, but the sad part is that it's usually the walk-ons that are willing to play mroe than 4 quarters just for the sake of playing.
Anonymous
Thu Feb 4 2010 16:59
Good letter, Mr. Greenberg. I agree. Walk-ons are a wonderful tradition at ND and the stuff of 'ND Lore'.

But Kelly is all business and is concerned about the final product (the Wins), not so much the the welfare of the students.

He'll make Notre Dame football a winner, but there is a price to pay for that.

Get used to it.

Alum "72

Anonymous
Thu Feb 4 2010 15:56
Wow. That is really surprising.
Anonymous
Thu Feb 4 2010 13:06
This is probably the first step. Athletic Dorms will be the second. The football team will separate itself from the student body.

I guess this is what the administration wanted.

73 alum
Thu Feb 4 2010 05:48
I presume Mike Oriard would agree!






log out