Skip to Content, Navigation, or Footer.
Monday, Dec. 22, 2025
The Observer

Opinion


The Observer

Determinism

·

 The controversy between free will and determinism continues to rage. In one way, this is unsurprising: The same controversy has raged, in one form or another, for two millennia, and it is clearly a question near to us in our understanding of ourselves. In another way, however, that the controversy continues is deeply surprising: Since the rise of quantum physics, it has been clear that our world is fundamentally indeterministic — that nothing, including human action, is bound by determinate laws.


The Observer

Your GPA and the end of the world

·

 Each mid-November, just as the perma-cloud settles in over South Bend, the days get depressingly shorter, and due dates for papers and exams start looming on the horizon — the Church starts talking about the end of the world. And while the Church Fathers who set the calendar surely couldn't have predicted the weather patterns or exam schedules of the university that Fr. Sorin had not yet founded, this talk about the end of the world these days seems somehow to, well, fit.



The Observer

Party at my place

·

Seriously. You are all invited. Although it will not be a typical Notre Dame party, it will be a good time.

The Observer

The actual facts

·

The statement "You cannot be pro-life and pro-choice at the same time" ("The facts," Anne Barbera, Nov. 17) is not a fact. There is no well-constructed fence that divides the abortion debate.


The Observer

Remember the Good

·

On Nov. 21, the seniors will play their last football game at Notre Dame Stadium. A lot will be made of it, and hopefully they will bounce back from the last couple of weeks and win their last home game.


The Observer

The Notre Dame 10

·

Today is the 40th anniversary of an important event in the life of Notre Dame. On Nov. 18, 1969, 10 students were suspended under the famous "15-minute rule" after a demonstration protesting the presence of recruiters from Dow Chemical and the CIA. The 15-minute rule, announced by Fr. Hesburgh earlier that year, was viewed nationally as a get-tough response to student protests. "Disruptive" students were to be given 15 minutes to "cease and desist." If they failed to disperse, they would be suspended. If they remained five minutes longer, they would be expelled and subject to arrest.


The Observer

True justice for terrorists

·

Christie Pesavento's Nov. 17 column "Taking terrorists at their word" is another absurd lash by the right wing in an attempt to smear the Obama administration. To suggest that the Obama administration is not taking the threat of terrorism seriously is an enormous misunderstanding of the Obama administration's commitment to the principles this nation was founded upon.




The Observer

Go ahead and 'kill'

·

I would like to add my support to Lizzie Laughman's letter in which she encouraged the student body to put competition aside for the UConn game ("Be class, respectful," Nov. 16). She's right — even though we just lost to Navy for the second time in three years, our main concern should be not to hurt the opposing team's feelings. Maybe we will win the coveted College Football Bowl Subdivision award for "Classiest Football Team" or "Nicest Student Body." We can put that trophy right next to the Jeweled Shillelagh and all of the BCS trophies we've won recently.


The Observer

Stay classy, ND

·

 This past weekend I attended the Notre Dame-Pitt game at Heinz Field. Despite the loss and the relatively poor performance that our team exhibited on the field, I came out of that game prouder than ever to be a member of the Notre Dame community. I don't think I have ever heard that many four letter words in my life, especially those directed to people who were quite obviously not Notre Dame students. The worst part is the Pitt insults were not even creative; their student section had only two chants throughout the entire game — "Let's go Pitt" and (more often) "F**k the Irish."


The Observer

Sparkle motion

·

 I am just as excited for the new "Twilight" movie as the next 21-year-old female. "New Moon" actually looks pretty darn entertaining. Everyone's hair looks better and the action sequences feature Dakota Fanning and the guy who plays Colossus in the X-Men movies. If the clips in the TV spots are any indication, this thing might be a legitimately "good" movie, as far as an adaptation of a clichéd and derivative publishing phenomenon can be.


The Observer

The facts

·

 You cannot be pro-life and pro-choice at the same time. I understand that abortion is a difficult issue, but you stand on one side of the fence or the other. While women do not take abortion lightly, easy access to abortion has caused the rate of repeat abortions to sky rocket.


The Observer

More importantly, be loud

·

 In response to Lizzie Laughman ("Be classy, respectful," Nov. 14), I would like to make my own request of all Notre Dame fans. I'll start with the following disclaimer. In no way is the "kill" chant related to Jasper Howard, and I guarantee that the UConn players, should they even hear the chant, wouldn't make that connection. Howard's death was tragic, but considering the context of the chant, that we are fans cheering on our team, I don't see how shouting "kill" would dishonor his memory. However, though I disagree with the self-important, politically correct, "We are ND; we're better than everyone else," attitude that seems to motivate Lizzie's call to not perform the chant, I see a way to reconcile her motives with a desire to make Notre Dame Stadium a more intimidating environment for our opponents.


The Observer

Slumbering echoes

·

 After Notre Dame's recent losses to Navy and Pitt, I have done a lot of thinking. I then came to the realization that something is terribly wrong with the Irish football team. However, since everybody has his or her own opinion on what needs to be changed, I will be as vague as humanly possible so nobody can tell me that I'm wrong. In fact, I'm going to format my rant as a mad-lib. Okay, here it goes:


The Observer

Long-term approach

·

 Once again, talk in the ND community is replete with the question: "Do we fire Devine, Faust, Davie, Willingham or Weis?" What has often prevailed in the past is the short-term "Blame the coach and find the next Rockne" solution, often carried out in a way that comes across to the general public as panic.


The Observer

Taking terrorists at their word

·

 In August of 1996, Osama bin Laden issued a fatwa to fellow Islamist supporters across the globe, declaring war against the United States.


The Observer

Fire Sports Editor

·

At this time in the football season, I think we at Notre Dame require a change in leadership. The Observer Sports Editor, Matt Gamber, has made inexplicable mistakes in his game predictions this year. I'm sure no one will forget that in the biggest game of the year against USC, Gamber picked our beloved Irish to lose. Though he was in the end correct, this is not the kind of support we need in such an emotionally-charged game. Just this last week, he picked a blowout win over Navy, completely overlooking and disrespecting a solid opponent and lulling Observer readers into a false sense of security. Maybe Gamber should spend more time crunching the numbers and watching film like a true sports analyst should, and less time going on walks with his significant other. Hopefully Fr. Jenkins and Mr. Swarbrick heed my advice: Gamber must go. Charles Nejedlyjunioroff campusNov. 10


The Observer

A recipe for memory

·

Every time I eat pancakes, I think of my grandfather. Something about the smells of syrup and fresh batter and the combination of those things melting in my mouth takes me back to my childhood.   When I was three years old, my mother and I would go to my grandparent's house every Tuesday morning, where my grandpa would make us pancakes. I still remember him standing at the stove in his bathrobe while Mom sat at the table with me. Those mornings are some of my earliest memories, yet I can still picture them clearly in my mind. Last week, Grampy passed away. And so I found myself boarding a bus for Cleveland to be with my family. As I stared into the endless cornfields along the Ohio turnpike, I was flooded with memories of Grampy. He, on the other hand, didn't remember much of anything by the end of his life, as is true of so many people who develop Alzheimer's disease. I began to wonder what memory really is, after all. Why am I able to vividly remember those Tuesday mornings when I was three years old, but in his last years of life my grandfather struggled to remember things as simple as the names of his grandchildren? And worst of all, what will happen if my own parents lose their memories, and will I someday also have Alzheimer's? When I arrived at my aunt's house last Thursday evening, I found my family hovered around a table covered in photographs. They were making display boards of pictures for the wake the following morning, but I found that the very process of looking at the pictures was most important. Each photo sparked a different memory. Some of the pictures triggered memories I did not even know I had, such as piling into my grandfather's old red Mustang convertible with my cousins for a ride around the neighborhood on a sunny summer afternoon. Scientists can explain memory, and I hope they continue to make progress in research about Alzheimer's. But all we need are our own experiences to understand how it all works. Years from now, you won't remember reading this column. Instead, you might have memories of sitting in the dining hall reading The Observer and talking to your friends. But if you happen to be eating pancakes, I can guarantee you they do not compare to the ones my grandfather made. One last thing about those pancakes: When I was still three years old and sitting in Grampy's kitchen, I asked my mom why his pancakes were so good. "They're made with a special ingredient," she told me. She paused, and I asked impatiently about this secret recipe. Grampy chuckled as Mom responded with just one word. "Love."